PUD floats idea of raising Lake Entiat levels

  • Post a comment
  • Print
  • Bookmark and Share

Learn more

Visit chelanpud.org for information about storing more Columbia River water in Chelan County, or call Kris Pomianek, the utility’s community liason: 661-4186.

Money and motives behind the water effort

The state Department of Ecology last year allocated $46.5 million of its $200 million state-approved financing for 18 projects to increase Columbia River water storage in Eastern Washington.

Among the projects are studies of potential storage sites at Rock Island Creek and Foster Coulee in Douglas County, a reservoir to reduce the need to draw from Peshastin Creek in Chelan County and storage sites on Colville tribal lands in Okanogan County.

The money and the mandate are part of the Columbia River Basin Water Management Act of 2006.

The act seeks to create more water for Eastern Washington irrigation, cities and river flows for fish during periods of drought.

A high-priority project is a new water supply for the increasingly dry farms of Odessa, east of Moses Lake.

Among Ecology’s earliest efforts was a study to identify sites to build a large water reservoirs.

Ecology spokeswoman Joye Redfield-Wilder said that plan was tabled due to its high environmental impact and cost.

The agency now seeks to study and fund smaller reservoirs and lower-cost options that include increasing water levels behind Columbia River dams.

The Bureau of Reclamation has begun a project to increase the level of Lake Roosevelt, behind Grand Coulee Dam, by 1 to 1.8 feet to create 82,5000 acre feet of new water.

Increasing the Rocky Reach reservoir would create 20,000 to 50,000 acre feet of new stored water.

Ecology is currently accepting public opinion on a proposal to raise the water level behind the Grant County PUD's Wanapum Dam by 3.5 feet. The proposal would create 70,000 acre feet of new stored water, but would partially flood Crescent Bar Island, a recreation and residential hot spot on the Columbia.

photo

Chelan County PUD commissioner

photo

Cashmere orchardist

photo

Director of energy resources, Chelan County PUD

This story previously reported incorrect information about Grant County PUD's dam license requirement. The error has been corrected in this version.

WENATCHEE — A state mandate to increase water supplies in the Columbia Basin could lead to a higher water level behind Rocky Reach Dam and projects to pump Columbia River water into dammed mountain canyons around the region.

Chelan County PUD commissioners Monday expressed interest in a proposal to work with the state Department of Ecology to identify water-storage sites around the county that could also generate electricity.

Ecology has a state mandate to increase the water supply in Eastern Washington by storing more Columbia River water for irrigation, city water supplies and to supplement streamflows for fish during times of drought, Ecology official Derek Sandison told commissioners Monday.

Sandison directs the agency’s Columbia Basin water-supply effort.

Commissioners plan to vote at their next meeting, Nov. 9, on an agreement to work with Ecology officials.

Gregg Carrington, the utility’s director of energy resources, said the agreement would be the first step in a potentially five-year process to explore water-storage potential and new sources of power generation in Chelan County.

The exploratory process would include ample opportunity for public comment, he said.

Carrington said water storage in Chelan County could happen by:

• Raising the level of the Rocky Reach Dam reservoir — called Lake Entiat — by 1 to 3 feet and releasing it during low-flow periods of late summer and fall.

• Pumping water from the river during periods of high flow to mountain reservoirs that could be built by damming dry canyons. The water would be released, as needed, to flow downhill back to the river.

Ecology would pay for studies into either alternative using part of the $200 million bonding authorization granted by the state Legislature in 2006 to increase water storage.

If research shows building mountain reservoirs is feasible, Carrington said PUD officials would urge Ecology to consider adding turbines that could generate electricity when the reservoir water is released and flows back to the river, Carrington said.

This system for generating electricity is called “pumped storage.”

Some 40 pumped-storage projects already operate around the country, and another 40 are in the permitting stage, including four in Washington, according to a study funded by the National Hydropower Association, an industry lobby group.

Carrington and PUD General Manager Rich Riazzi said pumped-storage projects are a cleaner alternative to natural gas-fired plants for producing electricity on demand at times when intermittent power sources, like wind farms, aren’t generating.

They also take advantage of surplus by using the electric pumps to fill the reservoir at times when power is plentiful, but other demand is low.

At a potential construction price of $1 billion a pumped-storage project would be a multi-agency effort that could include the region’s PUDs, the Bonneville Power Administration and Bureau of Reclamation, Carrington said.

The Chelan PUD would only pursue this option if state laws were changed to allow pumped-storage generation to count toward state quotas for renewable energy, Carrington said.

Private investors are exploring some of the state’s potential sites, Carrington said.

“We want to be the ones who are filing for permits for sites in our own back yards,” he said.

Commissioner Randy Smith described the PUD’s joint efforts with Ecology as “intriguing.” Commissioner Dennis Bolz said it has “tremendous potential.”

The PUD considered building a pumped-storage project at Antilon Lake, northeast of Manson, in the 1970s to provide supplemental power for the then growing nuclear energy, Carrington said.

A proposal in the 1990s to increase the Rocky Reach reservoir for power generation was rejected by federal regulators because of its then-unmeasurable impact on migratory fish — a problem that has since been resolved through modern fish-study technology, Carrington said.

Christine Pratt: 665-1173

pratt@wenatcheeworld.com

Comments

Want to comment on this story? Registered users can use the form below. Please know that we at wenatcheeworld.com hope our site is useful, entertaining and civil. So we'll delete comments that are obscene, abusive or way off topic. We appreciate it when readers use the "suggest removal" button to flag inappropriate comments. For more about interacting with the site, see our Use Policy.

Orphanthall (Nathan Smith) says...

The PUD should go forward with both raising Rocky Reach 3 feet and also pump generation plants. These are both clean effective ways to generate energy that is environmentally sound. A great pump generation system would be pumping Chelan water to Antilon Lake.

November 3, 2009 at 5 p.m. ( | suggest removal )

FEATURED ON WENATCHEEWORLD.COM

Phone: 509.663.5161

Copyright © 2009 World Publishing Co. All rights reserved.

Terms of Use   |   Privacy Policy   |   Use Policy