The Wenatchee World

Weather:

Weather

The latest extended forecast from The Weather Channel

Remove this weather forecast

Today

Hi69° Mostly Sunny

Tonight

Lo44° Partly Cloudy

Friday

Hi73° Sunny

Friday Night

Lo51° Increasing Clouds

Saturday

Hi77° Partly Sunny

Saturday Night

Lo52° Partly Cloudy

Sunday

Hi76° Sunny

Sunday Night

Lo53° Mostly Clear

Monday

Hi80° Sunny

Monday Night

Lo53° Mostly Clear

Secession is, as usual, just talk

Send to Kindle
Print This
You have to make the legal point at the outset: It is not possible for a state to secede from the union just by asking. You can file as many petitions as you like, but you can’t get out. When this or any state asked to join the union, and permission was granted, it became a permanent contract, unbreakable unilaterally. That was the understanding among many framers of the Constitution, according to scholars. If you were asleep in your junior high history class, you should be told that we fought a fairly significant war to settle the issue. There’s even a Supreme Court ruling, from 1868, that says the union of states is “indestructible.” Maybe, if the other states want you out, that’s a different matter. But generally, those of you who dream of a new Republic of (insert state here) are fooling yourselves. Which makes the talk lately about secession just fun, or stupid. What should trouble us is there really are people who think their state’s separation is not only possible, but a really good idea. There have always been these people, on left and right, one side getting more attention depending on who won the last election and who is eating the sour grapes.

View my optionsorSign in